Digital and AI
8 value drivers for maximising ROI in collections transformations
Nick Walsh, Consultant · · 4 minute read
Transforming your debt collections system is a substantial investment of time, money, and resources. However, not all transformations deliver their full potential.
Consultant, arum
What you need to know
- Most organisations use a fraction of what their collections platform can already do.
- Return comes from eight specific drivers, not from the size of the investment.
- Built-in remediation, forbearance and recurring payment tools are the most commonly left switched off.
Failing to fully use your debt collection platform can have a major impact on your business. Inefficiencies and lack of automation can increase regulatory compliance and conduct risk, as well as lead to poor customer outcomes. Without the right tools, insights and analytics, it becomes harder to scale, optimise performance, and stay competitive. Investing in a high-performing, intelligent collections system can drive stronger financial outcomes while protecting your brand and customer relationships.
So, what sets successful transformations apart from the rest?
Whether implementing a new platform, upgrading an existing system, or rethinking your overall arrears management model, these 8 key value drivers will help you maximise ROI.
1. Align technology choices with business goals
Successful transformations begin with a clear purpose. Before selecting debt collection software, define your objectives: enhancing customer experience and outcomes, reducing bad debt, increasing automation, or lowering operational costs.
Aligning system capabilities with business priorities ensures meaningful impact and prevents a 'technology for technology's sake' scenario.
My recommendation is to convert strategic objectives into measurable success metrics, such as improved customer engagement rates, improved forbearance kept rates, improved conduct risk metrics, or cost reduction.
2. Design with your customers in mind
It may sound obvious, but a modern collections platform must prioritise customer needs, ensuring clean transitions between digital and human interactions and maintaining a consistent, compliant experience across all channels.
Self-service portals can now match or exceed agent-led interactions, using business rules engines to guide customers effectively. Features such as dynamic interfaces, vulnerability detection, and real-time decisioning empower both agents and customers to make informed decisions.
Regulatory compliant, personalised and proactive communications can lead to collection performance improvements of 7% to 14%, with increased customer satisfaction.
3. Enhance control and compliance
A modern collections system significantly improves the control environment by embedding robust governance, risk management, and compliance capabilities.
Advanced audit trails, automated decision-making, and real-time monitoring ensure adherence to regulatory requirements while reducing the risk of human error. Features such as configurable workflows, role-based access controls, and integrated compliance checks enable organisations to enforce policies consistently.
This not only strengthens regulatory compliance but also enhances transparency and accountability, reducing the likelihood of costly breaches and reputational damage.
4. Use automation for operational efficiency
Modern collections systems offer automation across the entire lifecycle, from ID and Verification and payment arrangements, to vulnerability, forbearance support and privacy requests.
Automation enhances customer convenience while driving cost savings. Organisations have reported a 35% reduction in collections costs per account, alongside reduced inbound call volumes, abandonment rates, and field collections activities.
Furthermore, strategy deployment that once took a month can now be executed in a week, representing a 75% reduction in time-to-market for new collections strategies.
5. Continuously optimise through data-driven insights
Strong data foundations enable accurate reporting, increased MI capability, agile performance monitoring, and ongoing strategy development and refinement, all critical for continuous improvement.
Platforms ready for what comes next support structured data capture and integration via open APIs, facilitating smarter segmentation and more targeted collection strategies and treatments.
Organisations that embrace continuous improvement and measure and adjust strategies accordingly, have seen collections increase by up to 13% in previously deemed unrecoverable portfolios.
6. Consider speed to value and avoid reinvention
While custom-built solutions may seem flexible, they often extend time-to-value and create scalability challenges.
Proven, Commercial Off-The-Shelf (COTS) solutions offer:
Built-in tools for remediation, forbearance, and recurring payments
Secure, compliant architecture aligned with PCI DSS and SOC2 standards
Cloud-native scalability with continuous vendor-led innovation roadmaps
Choosing a platform with these capabilities accelerates implementation, reduces risk, and ensures faster ROI.
7. Invest in people, processes, and change management
Technology alone does not guarantee a return on investment. Adoption across teams, from frontline agents to back-office teams and analysts, is critical.
Modern debt collection systems simplify workflows, presenting only the most relevant information at the right time. Role-based interfaces and intuitive tools help agents follow best practices, particularly when dealing with vulnerable or complex cases.
To realise full ROI, organisations must invest in training, process alignment, and continuous performance feedback loops.
8. Select the right vendors and partners
The success of your transformation depends on the expertise of your vendors and partners. Selecting providers with sector experience and deep knowledge of both the technology and the collections industry can determine whether your project is a delayed implementation or a transformative success.
Summary
Maximising ROI from a collections system transformation requires more than just new technology, it demands a strategic, customer-centric, and data-driven approach. By focusing on the 8 value drivers outlined above, organisations can unlock the full potential of their investment, drive sustainable financial performance, and deliver better outcomes for both the business and its customers.
The difference between a good transformation and a great one lies in execution: partnering with the right experts, enabling your people, and keeping your strategic objectives front and centre throughout the journey.
How arum can help
At arum, we've supported some of the most complex and high-profile collections system transformations across both the public and private sectors. We can help you with the entire end-to-end process, including business case development, system and vendor evaluation, delivery and design support, post-go-live optimisation, and Target Operating Model design. If you're planning or already in the midst of a transformation, we can help ensure you maximise your investment's return and deliver on time.
We also run the only accreditation specifically for collections and recoveries platforms. With an in-depth knowledge base of over 30 vendors (including C&R Software Debt Manager, CGI CACS X, Finvi Katabat, Latitude by Genesys, E xperian PowerCurve Collections, Exus EFS, Flexys Control+, Telrock Optimus, Qualco QCR, Tietoevry Collection Suite Nova, Lateral, and Financial Cloud, as well as many others ), and regular engagement with the market, we offer unmatched insights and recommendations tailored to client needs.
From the same author
More from Nick Walsh.
Regulatory changeBNPL regulation confirmed: what it means for consumers and lenders
The UK government has confirmed that third-party BNPL products will be regulated by the FCA from mid-2026. What it means for consumers and lenders.
Nick Walsh · 26 June 2025
Regulatory changeCFPB reverses course: Moves to scrap medical debt reporting ban
The CFPB has asked a federal court to vacate its own rule banning medical debt from consumer credit reports. What the reversal means for US collections.
Nick Walsh · 14 May 2025
Regulatory changeAchieving compliance with the Consumer Duty: Removing sludge practices
One of the key parts of the FCA's Consumer Duty, and in particular the consumer support outcome, is the eradication of sludge processes.
Nick Walsh · 18 March 2025
Keep reading
More from arum.
Digital and AIWhat three weeks at MIT taught us about building agentic AI
Ella and Matt took MIT's agentic AI course to pressure-test the AI-assisted system arum was already building. Here is what held up and what did not.
Matt Riddall and Ella Grice · 17 June 2026
Digital and AIBuy vs. build for debt collection platforms
In today's economic and regulatory environment, transforming collections capability is high on organisations' strategic imperatives.
Reuben Gates · 13 May 2026
Digital and AIIs your AI agent actually ready? 11 questions to ask first
Eleven questions to answer before an AI agent handles a customer in arrears, from a team that has been building them since 2019.
Matt Riddall · 2 April 2026
Talk to arum
