Regulatory change

Affordability assessment in collections: methods, data and what the rules expect

Katie Harris, Senior Consultant · · 10 minute read
UK

Katie Harris, Senior Consultant at arumKatie Harris
Senior Consultant, arum

What you need to know

  • An effective affordability assessment is not simply about collecting financial information. It is about using that information to make fair, informed and sustainable decisions that reflect the customer's individual circumstances.
  • The Standard Financial Statement, or an appropriate equivalent, should be the consistent baseline however an assessment is completed. Telephone, paper and digital approaches each suit different customers, and open banking supports an assessment rather than replacing it.
  • A positive disposable income figure does not mean the full amount is available for debt repayment. Where there is little or none, forbearance, a payment pause, a reduced arrangement or a referral to debt advice may be the right outcome.
  • Assessments go wrong when targets, training, system limits or rigid repayment rules shape the decision more than the customer's circumstances do.
  • The FCA does not require a formal income and expenditure assessment in every case. Where a firm undertakes one, it must be objective, and firms must take all reasonable steps to ensure agreed repayment arrangements are sustainable. Ofgem requires energy suppliers to take customers' ability to pay into account.

Why this still needs saying

Income and expenditure assessments have been part of collections for as long as most of us can remember, and it is easy to assume every firm has them sorted. Doing them well is less common than that suggests. Broken arrangements, customers who stop engaging after the first call, and plans that were never realistic often trace back to how the assessment was done. Both the FCA and Ofgem have also put more weight on affordability in the last two years, so it is a good time to look again at how yours works in practice.

The point to hold on to is that an effective assessment is not simply about collecting financial information. It is about using that information to make fair, informed and sustainable decisions that reflect each customer's circumstances.

What does an affordability assessment have to establish?

It has to establish what the customer can pay, and for how long, while still meeting their essential living costs and priority debts such as rent or mortgage, council tax and energy. It should also establish whether an arrangement is the right step at all, or whether the customer first needs time, free debt advice or more specialist support.

In practice that means understanding:

  • household income, how regular it is, and how much it varies
  • essential living costs, using actual figures wherever the customer has them
  • irregular or annual expenditure, which a monthly snapshot can miss
  • other debts, and which of them are priority debts
  • changes in household circumstances, and financial commitments the customer can already foresee
  • any vulnerability or additional support needs that affect what the customer can manage, or how they want to be contacted
  • when the arrangement should be reviewed, and what happens if circumstances change

Affordability is about more than calculating disposable income. A positive disposable income figure does not automatically mean the full amount is available for debt repayment, and an arrangement that takes all of it leaves no room for the costs a budget does not capture.

Where an assessment shows that a customer has little or no disposable income, a repayment plan may not be the right outcome. Forbearance, a temporary payment pause, a reduced arrangement or a referral to independent debt advice may be more appropriate, with a point agreed to review it.

Which approaches are in use, and when does each suit the customer?

The Standard Financial Statement (SFS) is a framework for capturing and assessing financial information. It is not a way of obtaining that information. Firms should use the SFS, or an appropriate equivalent, as a consistent baseline however the assessment is completed.

The approaches below are ways of completing it. The right one depends on the customer's preferences, accessibility needs and any additional support they need, and many customers will use more than one.

Telephone or adviser-led

  • When it is most suitable: Customers who prefer to talk through their finances, need something clarified or would benefit from guidance. Often the right route where there are several debts, variable income or circumstances requiring additional explanation, provided a telephone conversation is suitable for their individual communication and support needs.
  • Benefits for the customer: Questions are answered as they go, and the adviser can pick up circumstances the customer might not think to mention.
  • What good practice looks like: Trained advisers working to a consistent framework, time to do it properly, and a record of the assessment offered to the customer.

Paper or postal

  • When it is most suitable: Customers who need additional time to process information, have limited digital access, or want to seek independent advice or support before completing it.
  • Benefits for the customer: Time to gather figures and think at their own pace, with someone they trust if they wish.
  • What good practice looks like: Clear, accessible forms built on a consistent assessment framework, sufficient time for completion, support available when required, and appropriate follow-up that respects the customer's circumstances and preferred communication method.

Digital self-service

  • When it is most suitable: Customers who prefer independence and flexibility and can use it confidently.
  • Benefits for the customer: Completed when it suits them, without waiting for a call.
  • What good practice looks like: Accessible design, clear instructions, the ability to save progress where possible, and an easy route to human support at any stage. Customers should be able to complete the assessment at their own pace without unnecessary pressure.

Open banking (a supporting tool)

  • When it is most suitable: Customers who are comfortable sharing transaction data, with consent.
  • Benefits for the customer: Can reduce the need to gather and provide financial information manually, while helping customers and advisers review historic income and spending patterns.
  • What good practice looks like: Used to support the assessment, not to replace it. Spending data shows what a household has spent, which can differ from what it needs, and customers who prefer not to use it get the same quality of assessment.

What do the FCA and Ofgem expect?

FCA: borrowers in financial difficulty

The FCA's rules for borrowers in financial difficulty, set out in PS24/2, came into force on 4 November 2024. There is no blanket requirement to carry out a formal income and expenditure assessment in every case. Where a firm does carry one out, it must be done objectively, for example by reference to the Standard Financial Statement or an equivalent tool. Where possible, firms should give the customer a record of the assessment so they can share it with other lenders and debt advice providers.

Firms must take all reasonable steps to ensure that any agreed repayment arrangements are sustainable, taking account of the customer's priority debts and essential living expenses. An arrangement is unlikely to be sustainable if it leaves the customer unable to meet priority debts and essential living expenses. Under the Consumer Duty, firms also need to evidence that customers in financial difficulty get good outcomes, so the assessment, and what happens after it, is part of that evidence.

Ofgem: ability to pay in energy

Energy suppliers are required to take customers' ability to pay into account when establishing debt repayment arrangements.

In October 2026, the Government and Ofgem published their joint strategy for domestic energy debt, reporting that electricity and gas debt and arrears across Great Britain had reached approximately £5 billion in Q2 2026.

The strategy specifically identifies improving income and expenditure assessments as a priority. Ofgem and the Government intend to work with suppliers, debt advice organisations and other stakeholders to improve the consistency and effectiveness of assessments, including consideration of recognised frameworks such as the Standard Financial Statement and the Common Financial Statement used in Scotland.

This reinforces the importance of understanding individual circumstances, applying consistent assessment principles and ensuring that repayment arrangements are affordable and sustainable.

The strategy also sets out plans for a single-phase Debt Relief Scheme, currently expected to launch in spring 2027, subject to consultation and final decisions. The scheme is intended to support eligible customers experiencing genuine financial difficulty with historic energy debt accumulated during the 2022 to 2024 energy crisis.

Where do affordability assessments go wrong?

In my experience, affordability assessments most often fail when completing the form becomes the objective, rather than understanding what the customer can sustain. A customer agreeing to an amount does not, by itself, make it affordable, and repeated broken arrangements should prompt a review of the assessment and support offered.

Inconsistent assessments are not always caused by the assessment method itself. They can also be influenced by operational targets, agent training, system limitations and the options available to staff when making repayment decisions. Minimum repayment expectations, rigid repayment periods or system-driven affordability calculations can result in arrangements that appear reasonable operationally but are not sustainable for the customer. That is why affordability needs to be embedded into operational processes and decision-making, rather than treated as a standalone exercise.

I would steer firms towards a proportionate, customer-led assessment, supported by a consistent income and expenditure framework that reflects actual household circumstances, essential costs, other debts and any vulnerability or additional support needs. A conversation can be particularly valuable where clarification or guidance is required, but customers should also have access to alternative approaches that suit their circumstances. The Standard Financial Statement or an equivalent approach can provide consistency, while open banking can help customers share information where they choose to use it.

I would steer firms away from rigid repayment periods, minimum payment targets and expenditure benchmarks treated as hard limits. Those approaches can produce a tidy repayment plan on screen that bears little relationship to the customer's life. The real test is whether the assessment leads to an appropriate arrangement, with a clear rationale and a review when circumstances change.

How do you keep a good assessment cost effective?

Offering customers the opportunity to complete an assessment independently can improve flexibility, accessibility and efficiency. However, the chosen approach should reflect the customer's preferences and support needs, rather than simply reducing operational handling time. Where additional assistance is required, firms should ensure this remains readily available. Shortening the call by sending the customer a form can simply transfer the effort to someone who may already be struggling, increasing the risk of disengagement and an unresolved debt. Digital self-service has a valuable role where customers can use it confidently, with support available when needed; it should not become a way to avoid a necessary conversation.

Firms should make the process more cost effective through simpler journeys, reuse of relevant information and segmentation that directs effort according to financial circumstances, complexity and support needs. Customers with straightforward circumstances may need a lighter assessment, while those with multiple debts, unstable income or additional needs may require more time and specialist help. Segmentation is key, but it must remain responsive to what the customer tells you. The aim should be to reduce avoidable effort and failed arrangements, rather than judge efficiency by call duration alone.

How do you know your approach is working?

Measuring effectiveness means looking beyond assessment records and whether arrangements are maintained. When reviewing a firm's approach, the questions that matter are whether assessments are completed consistently, whether customer circumstances influence the decisions made, and whether the resulting arrangements are sustainable.

For each customer, a firm should be able to show how the assessment was done and what the arrangement was based on. That usually includes:

  • the framework used, and where each figure came from
  • any adjustment to the customer's figures, with the reason for it
  • the rationale for the arrangement, including why it is sustainable
  • how any vulnerability or support need was taken into account
  • that the customer was offered a record of the assessment
  • when the arrangement was reviewed, and what happened when a payment was missed or circumstances changed

Across the book, management information such as broken arrangements, repeat assessments, complaints and quality assurance findings, split by customer group and channel, can help identify potential issues. It needs reading with care. An arrangement remaining active does not necessarily demonstrate affordability, just as a broken arrangement does not automatically mean the original assessment was poor.

Management information should not simply be collected and reported. Firms should be able to demonstrate how findings are used to identify potential weaknesses, challenge existing practices, improve decision-making and assess whether those changes deliver better outcomes for customers.

Additional data and analytical tools can help firms identify customers who may require further support or a more detailed assessment. These tools should complement, rather than replace, the customer's own financial information and individual circumstances. Firms must also understand the limitations of the data and ensure that automated recommendations do not result in inappropriate repayment decisions.

How arum helps

arum works with collections and recoveries teams in financial services and utilities to improve how affordability is assessed and acted on. Alongside reviewing assessment frameworks and customer journeys, we bring expertise in collections operations, process design, system capabilities, operational controls and performance assurance. Bringing these together helps firms improve the quality of their assessments, run their operations more effectively and show that the arrangements they agree deliver sustainable outcomes for customers.

Next step

If you want to know whether your affordability assessments would stand up to the FCA's or Ofgem's expectations, talk to Katie or one of our experts. We can show you where the process is working, where it is costing you broken arrangements, and what to change first.

Questions we are asked about this

Do firms have to carry out an income and expenditure assessment?

Under the FCA's rules for borrowers in financial difficulty, there is no blanket requirement to carry out a formal income and expenditure assessment in every case. Where a firm undertakes an assessment, it must be done objectively and informed by sufficiently detailed information. Firms must also take all reasonable steps to ensure any agreed repayment arrangements are sustainable, including consideration of the customer's priority debts and essential living expenses.

Is the Standard Financial Statement a method of assessment?

It is a framework for capturing and assessing financial information, used as a consistent baseline. The assessment itself can be completed by telephone, on paper or online. Its spending guidelines work best as a check on whether a customer's figures look reasonable. Treated as hard limits, they can produce a plan that looks tidy on screen and does not match the customer's actual costs.

Does open banking replace the income and expenditure assessment?

No. It is a useful supporting tool for gathering financial information, for customers who choose to use it. Transaction data shows what a household has spent, which can differ from what it needs, so it works alongside the assessment.

What if the assessment shows little or no disposable income?

A repayment plan may not be the right outcome. Forbearance, a temporary payment pause, a reduced arrangement or a referral to independent debt advice may be more appropriate, with a point agreed to review it.

What should happen when an arrangement keeps breaking?

Repeated broken arrangements should prompt a review of the assessment and the support offered, as the original amount may never have been sustainable. A single broken arrangement does not automatically mean the assessment was poor, which is why the pattern matters more than any one case.

About the author

Katie Harris

Senior Consultant, arum

Katie has over 20 years of experience in collections and recoveries. She has led innovative projects spanning system selection, configuration, and business readiness, with a particular passion for elevating customer experience and designing streamlined internal processes that benefit both customers and employees.

Filed underRegulatory change

Talk to arum

Talk this through with arum

Send a short note about your operation and we will be in touch.
What are you evaluating? required